Weird-Two key UBS merchants anxiety about financial institution’s dimension, regulatory friction

Two key UBS merchants anxiety about financial institution's dimension, regulatory friction
© Reuters. FILE PHOTO: Logos of Swiss banks Credit Suisse and UBS are viewed earlier than a news conference in Zurich Switzerland, August 30, 2023. REUTERS/Denis Balibouse/File Photo

By Stefania Spezzati and Oliver Hirt

LONDON/ZURICH (Reuters) – UBS is forging ahead with its integration of Credit Suisse but two key merchants be concerned the Swiss financial institution could be on a collision direction with regulators resulting from its dimension.

UBS took over its rival in a hiss-orchestrated rescue closing 365 days, developing a financial institution with a stability sheet of greater than $1.6 trillion, virtually twice the scale of the Swiss financial system. Its shares are up about 50% since March, when the deal used to be launched, outperforming the Stoxx European Banks Index.

However shareholder service firm Ethos, which advises purchasers that in total have between 3% and 5% of UBS’s shares, is occupied with the affect the financial institution can have on future banking law, doubtlessly undermining Switzerland’s skill to rein in possibility-taking.

One other investor, a high 10 shareholder who spoke to Reuters on condition of anonymity, said the chance of persistent warfare with Swiss regulators and lawmakers over the financial institution’s dimension could bog down the tender working of the lender.

For Switzerland, the stakes are excessive.

UBS dominates obvious aspects of the Swiss banking market, similar to industrial lending, and could pose a possibility to the financial system must it receive into bother.

UBS’s takeover of its rival induced a debate about whether the too-vast-to-fail regulatory framework that emerged from the financial disaster in 2008 is fit for motive.

Globally systemically important banks — similar to UBS — are required to situation for resolution, which must allow regulators to unwind them without broader systemic repercussions. Resolution for Credit Suisse used to be regarded as but no longer pursued.

Within the spring, the Swiss finance ministry will post to the parliament a overview of the country’s systemically important banks after the occasions in March closing 365 days.

“We are aloof very disquieted about the scale of UBS in particular when in contrast with the Swiss market,” Vincent Kaufmann, CEO of Ethos urged Reuters.

“We compare the possible distortion of competition in quite so a lot of businesses and a concentration of dangers in obvious activities.”

Switzerland has a “too-extensive-to-fail” discipline now which requires “worthy regulations and much more resources to the supervisory physique,” he added.

“Regulations must require stronger capital glum. UBS will indubitably lobby against that and its increased dimension will doubtlessly have a higher affect on the legislative direction of,” Kaufmann said.


UBS said the specialize in its stability sheet is deceptive. It holds spherical 20% of total belongings in highly liquid belongings and one other 15% in mortgages to retail and prosperous purchasers, which undergo very low dangers, it said in e-mailed comments to Reuters.

The financial institution’s stability sheet will be additional reduced over the following three years and “aspects to put collectively for a doable resolution are in field and could simply be additional improved for the mixed financial institution,” UBS said.

Then all over again, the topic for UBS will be working a alternate which rewards merchants but is furthermore acceptable for regulators from a possibility point of view, the pinnacle 10 shareholder urged Reuters.

The Swiss finance watchdog FINMA and the central financial institution must delight in with its alternate mannequin, the pinnacle 10 shareholder said, otherwise there could be friction over the hazards that a financial institution of its dimension poses.

If UBS wishes to dwell a Swiss financial institution, resolving the controversy spherical law in its dwelling country is a wanted condition, the pinnacle 10 shareholder said.

Within the interval in-between, UBS must mitigate dangers in its stability sheet, the particular person added, expressing self belief within the present management but furthermore highlighting the necessity to put collectively a sound succession idea.

CEO Sergio Ermotti has previously said he plans to preserve on the helm of UBS by 2026.

FINMA, which has wonderful appointed a original CEO, declined to comment when contacted by Reuters.

A Swiss National Bank spokesperson said that in demand of UBS’s higher systemic significance and the linked dangers for Switzerland, the country’s authorities must carry a radical analysis and learn classes from Credit Suisse.


Regulators are aloof no longer ready must UBS ever need public enhance, a senior policymaker thinking about an emergency neighborhood field up by Swiss regulators for Credit Suisse in 2022, urged Reuters, speaking on condition of anonymity.

In an interview with Swiss newspaper NZZ on Saturday, Swiss Life Chairman Rolf Dörig, said that the original UBS used to be “too vast for the country. If UBS needed to be rescued, it can probably be devastating.”

However some merchants are drawn to UBS’s boost draw, that can simply sort out the wealth alternate globally and on its retail and company banking operations in Switzerland.

Cevian Capital in December said it had constructed up a 1.3% stake, having a wager on a two-fold recovery of its shares.

“As soon as the integration is total, the original financial institution is maybe no longer worthy bigger than the extra special UBS,” Andreas Thomae at Deka Funding, which in accordance to LSEG recordsdata holds 0.12% shares within the financial institution, said.

The combination is a multi-365 days process that can involve hundreds of job cuts in Switzerland and in various locations.

“By insecure, UBS is furthermore accommodating Swiss politics,” Thomae said.

Be taught Extra